Embedded Files
Avdiivka Front, Ukraine - August 2023. The rage of Lieutenant-Colonel Dmitri Volkov, commander of an artillery battalion, was as cold and hard as the frozen mud of his command bunker. It was a rage born of impotence. For months, his batteries of 2S19 Msta self-propelled howitzers—the pride of the Russian army, the inheritors of the Soviet "God of War"—had been falling silent. His daily ammunition allotment, once a river of steel, had dwindled to a pathetic trickle. Ten shells per gun, per day. A humiliating ration that turned his powerful, modern cannons into little more than static iron monuments.
He watched on a crackling drone feed as a Ukrainian infantry squad, feeling emboldened by the silent Russian guns, moved openly across a field, reinforcing a forward position. A perfect target. A beautiful target. A year ago, in the battle for Severodonetsk, he would have erased that squad from the earth with a single, contemptuous command, a casual expenditure of steel. Now, his crews were under strict, inviolable orders to fire only on high-priority armor or confirmed command posts. He was forced to watch, to cede the initiative and the battlefield to an enemy he held in contempt, all for the lack of simple, cheap iron and powder. His reports to headquarters, sent over the secure network, had become a repetitive, desperate scream into the void: I cannot provide suppressive fire. I cannot conduct counter-battery. I have no shells. The infantry is taking catastrophic losses. He was a commander of the world’s most powerful artillery army, and he was being defeated by empty ammunition crates and the abject failure of his country’s logisticians.
Kanggye, North Korea - September 2023. The air in Munitions Factory No. 26, a sprawling, dimly-lit complex carved into a granite mountain, was thick with the smells of hot metal, acrid chemicals, and the cheap, cabbage-heavy lunch of a thousand workers. A woman named Park, her face perpetually smudged with grease, worked the stenciling station. For a week, since the Marshal's triumphant return from Russia, the order had been relentless: Production Rate ‘Maximum.’ Her job was to take the newly forged 152mm artillery shells—still warm from the press—and paint over the old Korean People’s Army markings. She sprayed a hurried coat of olive-drab paint, then, using a fresh Cyrillic stencil, she carefully sprayed the Russian designation and a false, recent manufacturing date: ‘OF-540 / 3-23-F.’ It felt strange, almost sacrilegious, to erase the markings of her own glorious army. But the orders, which had come from the Marshal himself, were absolute. These shells were for their new, great Russian comrades, fighting the same American imperialist enemy. She worked with a fierce, patriotic pride, a small cog in a great machine that was now, finally, turning the wheels of history.
Packed in rough, splintery wooden crates, the shell Park had just stenciled began its long journey. It was loaded by conscripts onto a rumbling, soot-belching freight train that carried it east under the cover of a moonless night. Its destination was the port of Najin, a once-sleepy harbor now buzzing with a frantic, around-the-clock energy. There, it was swung high in a rusty crane’s net and lowered into the cavernous hold of a nondescript cargo ship, the Rusich. The ship’s AIS transponder was silent. It was a ghost, its hold filling with thousands of identical crates, a floating armory setting sail into the stormy Sea of Japan.
Avdiivka Front, Ukraine - January 2024. Dmitri Volkov no longer had to scream. He stood on a wooden platform behind his gun line, the ground trembling with a ceaseless, concussive roar. His "shell hunger" was over. But it had been replaced by a new, gnawing anxiety. The river of steel from the east was a poisoned one. The young private who loaded the next shell, the one stenciled by Park four months prior, heaved it toward the breach of a 2S19 Msta. "They feel heavier, Comrade Colonel," he grunted. "And the casings are rough." Volkov just nodded. His crews now treated their own ammunition like an enemy. The dud rate was appalling, maybe one in five thudding uselessly into the mud. But the true terror was the catastrophic in-barrel detonation. They had lost one gun and its crew two days ago when a faulty propellant charge had turned the howitzer into a makeshift bomb. His crews, once the proud professionals of the artillery corps, now flinched and half-turned away every time they pulled the lanyard, a terrifying game of Russian roulette with their own shells.
Still, the orders from headquarters were the same: Fire without limit. Erase them.
The fire mission came in. A Ukrainian fortification. The private shoved the North Korean shell into the breach, his movements now hesitant, almost prayerful. The commander gave the order. With a deafening roar, the shell was sent on the final seconds of its long journey. By pure chance, this one was not a dud. It arced through the gray sky and detonated, precisely as intended, above a trench, releasing a deadly shower of shrapnel. A direct, visceral line—from Park's stencil in the mountain factory, through the ghost ship and the trans-continental railway, to Volkov's desperate gamble—had just been drawn in the blood and soil of the Donbas.
Kanggye, North Korea - September 2023. The air in Munitions Factory No. 26, a sprawling, dimly-lit complex carved into a granite mountain, was thick with the smells of hot metal, acrid chemicals, and the cheap, cabbage-heavy lunch of a thousand workers. A woman named Park, her face perpetually smudged with grease, worked the stenciling station. For a week, since the Marshal's triumphant return from Russia, the order had been relentless: Production Rate ‘Maximum.’ Her job was to take the newly forged 152mm artillery shells—still warm from the press—and paint over the old Korean People’s Army markings. She sprayed a hurried coat of olive-drab paint, then, using a fresh Cyrillic stencil, she carefully sprayed the Russian designation and a false, recent manufacturing date: ‘OF-540 / 3-23-F.’ It felt strange, almost sacrilegious, to erase the markings of her own glorious army. But the orders, which had come from the Marshal himself, were absolute. These shells were for their new, great Russian comrades, fighting the same American imperialist enemy. She worked with a fierce, patriotic pride, a small cog in a great machine that was now, finally, turning the wheels of history.
Packed in rough, splintery wooden crates, the shell Park had just stenciled began its long journey. It was loaded by conscripts onto a rumbling, soot-belching freight train that carried it east under the cover of a moonless night. Its destination was the port of Najin, a once-sleepy harbor now buzzing with a frantic, around-the-clock energy. There, it was swung high in a rusty crane’s net and lowered into the cavernous hold of a nondescript cargo ship, the Rusich. The ship’s AIS transponder was silent. It was a ghost, its hold filling with thousands of identical crates, a floating armory setting sail into the stormy Sea of Japan.
Avdiivka Front, Ukraine - January 2024. Dmitri Volkov no longer had to scream. He stood on a wooden platform behind his gun line, the ground trembling with a ceaseless, concussive roar. His "shell hunger" was over. But it had been replaced by a new, gnawing anxiety. The river of steel from the east was a poisoned one. The young private who loaded the next shell, the one stenciled by Park four months prior, heaved it toward the breach of a 2S19 Msta. "They feel heavier, Comrade Colonel," he grunted. "And the casings are rough." Volkov just nodded. His crews now treated their own ammunition like an enemy. The dud rate was appalling, maybe one in five thudding uselessly into the mud. But the true terror was the catastrophic in-barrel detonation. They had lost one gun and its crew two days ago when a faulty propellant charge had turned the howitzer into a makeshift bomb. His crews, once the proud professionals of the artillery corps, now flinched and half-turned away every time they pulled the lanyard, a terrifying game of Russian roulette with their own shells.
Still, the orders from headquarters were the same: Fire without limit. Erase them.
The fire mission came in. A Ukrainian fortification. The private shoved the North Korean shell into the breach, his movements now hesitant, almost prayerful. The commander gave the order. With a deafening roar, the shell was sent on the final seconds of its long journey. By pure chance, this one was not a dud. It arced through the gray sky and detonated, precisely as intended, above a trench, releasing a deadly shower of shrapnel. A direct, visceral line—from Park's stencil in the mountain factory, through the ghost ship and the trans-continental railway, to Volkov's desperate gamble—had just been drawn in the blood and soil of the Donbas.
Discourse 50: Quantity Has a Quality All Its Own
Discourse 50: Quantity Has a Quality All Its Own
50.1 The Attritional Trap: Russia's Self-Inflicted Crisis
By the middle of 2023, the Russian military found itself ensnared in an attritional trap of its own making. The initial "Special Military Operation," predicated on a flawed political assumption of a swift Ukrainian collapse, had failed. The war had devolved from a contest of maneuver into a brutal mathematics of industrial production, a form of grinding warfare more reminiscent of 1916 than 2022. This style of conflict is won not by tactical brilliance alone, but by a nation's ability to produce and sustain a river of steel—artillery shells, rockets, and bombs—to feed the insatiable appetite of the front line. The Russian Federation, for all its posturing as a military superpower, was catastrophically unprepared for this reality. Its "just-in-time" military-industrial complex, optimized for short, high-tech conflicts, proved incapable of rapidly scaling up to meet the voracious consumption rates of a full-scale conventional war. Having expended a vast portion of its pre-war stockpiles in the first year, Russia faced a humiliating and dangerous "shell hunger," a crisis that blunted its offensive power and forced its artillery, the traditional "God of War" in Soviet and Russian doctrine, into a state of relative silence. As analysts Michael Kofman and others observed, Russia was now losing the industrial war to a Western coalition, a strategic failure of the highest order. See [citation 1]. This desperation forced the Kremlin to look for an outside lifeline, turning to the one state on earth whose entire national existence was a preparation for exactly this kind of war.
50.2 An Arsenal Frozen in Time: Why North Korea Was the Perfect Partner
Faced with its own industrial shortfalls and a global sanctions regime, Moscow had few options. Iran could provide drones and some missiles, but lacked a truly massive, Cold War-style artillery arsenal. China, while a powerful strategic partner, was ultimately unwilling to risk devastating secondary sanctions by providing overt, large-scale lethal aid. This left only the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. For over half a century, governed by the state ideology of Juche (self-reliance) and, more formally since the 1990s, by the Songun ("military-first") policy, the DPRK had singularly prioritized the development of its armed forces above all else, even at the cost of catastrophic famine. See [citation 2]. Its entire society and economy have been engineered to serve as a subsidiary to its military, creating a profoundly asymmetric nation: a failing state fused to an immense and singularly productive military-industrial complex, albeit one frozen in the technology of the 1970s. As catalogued by institutions like the International Institute for Strategic Studies, North Korea possessed one of the largest stockpiles of Soviet-caliber 122mm and 152mm artillery shells and rockets in the world—a mountain of simple, crude iron. It was a nation that had been preparing for a 1950s-style war of massed firepower for seventy years; in 2023, that anachronistic obsession suddenly made it Russia's most indispensable military partner.
50.3 Mapping the "Artillery Express": An Open-Source Investigation
Following the Putin-Kim summit in September 2023, a massive logistical operation, dubbed the "Artillery Express," commenced. Crucially, the evidence for this operation was not hidden in classified intelligence briefs but was meticulously documented in the open-source domain. Organizations like the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) and the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) used commercial satellite imagery to provide near-real-time proof of the supply chain. Their detailed reports featured satellite photos showing hundreds, then thousands, of shipping containers being amassed at North Korea's port of Najin. See [citation 3]. Subsequent imagery captured these same containers being loaded onto Russian-flagged cargo ships which, in a blatant attempt to hide their activity, "went dark" by deactivating their AIS transponders. The ships were then tracked to the formerly sleepy Russian naval pier at Dunai, near Vladivostok, where imagery showed them offloading their cargo. This visual evidence trail constituted an open-and-shut case of a massive, systematic arms transfer, in flagrant violation of the very UN Security Council resolutions that Russia itself had voted to impose on North Korea, a fact meticulously documented by the UN's own Panel of Experts before Russia disbanded it. See [citation 4].
50.4 "Quantity Has a Quality All Its Own": Reshaping the Battlefield
On the battlefield, the impact of this lifeline was immediate and profound. While Ukrainian soldiers and international forensic teams recovering shell fragments noted the often-poor quality and high dud rates of the North Korean munitions, their sheer quantity changed the arithmetic of the war. Stalin's old dictum that "quantity has a quality all its own" was proven true once more. According to South Korean and US intelligence estimates, North Korea has shipped as many as five million artillery shells to Russia. This single, massive infusion allowed the Russian army to overcome its "shell hunger" and re-establish a crushing firepower advantage over a Ukrainian army that was, by early 2024, suffering from its own ammunition famine caused by delays in Western aid. On key sectors of the front, this advantage reached an estimated seven-to-one or even ten-to-one ratio. This ability to generate overwhelming, indiscriminate firepower, regardless of its poor quality, was the decisive factor in the grueling battle for and eventual fall of the Ukrainian fortress city of Avdiivka in February 2024. A destitute pariah state had become the single most important military backer of a supposed global superpower, a reality that reshaped the entire tactical landscape of the war.
Page updated
Report abuse